inception-app-prod/YzE0OGY1NzEtYzc0Zi00OTFiLWEwNTctMzJjNzIyMmRmMDc1/content/2026/01/51e49e76075f4043ce9d6ac41217e292138c475a.png
215.704.5057
The Javada Hill Team logo
A real estate company with a purpose. Our mission is to help
inception-app-prod/YzE0OGY1NzEtYzc0Zi00OTFiLWEwNTctMzJjNzIyMmRmMDc1/content/2026/01/51e49e76075f4043ce9d6ac41217e292138c475a.png
215.704.5057
The Javada Hill Team logo
A real estate company with a purpose. Our mission is to help
inception-app-prod/YzE0OGY1NzEtYzc0Zi00OTFiLWEwNTctMzJjNzIyMmRmMDc1/content/2026/01/51e49e76075f4043ce9d6ac41217e292138c475a.png
215.704.5057
The Javada Hill Team logo
A real estate company with a purpose. Our mission is to help
Back to search
PA
Franklin
Greencastle
greencastle borough
17225
Search similar
PA
Franklin
Greencastle
greencastle borough
17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
67 Photos
Unsave
Save

$385,000

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225

ACTIVE
67 Photos
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
Unsave
Save
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225

Information

Price: $385,000
Days On Market: 14
Year Build: 1840
Total Baths: 3
Full Baths: 3
Bedrooms: 4
MLS ID: PAFL2034148
Status: Active

Details

Address: 46 N CARLISLE STREET
County: Franklin
City: Greencastle
Neighborhood: greencastle borough
Zip: 17225
State: Pennsylvania

Taxes

Property Taxes: $3,520
Tax Year: 2025
Tax Amount: $3,520

Description

The Historic Hollar House (c. 1840), located in Greencastle, PA, is a distinguished landmark within the historic downtown. It holds special significance as the first home of the Greencastle Circulating Library Association. This charming residence offers 4 bedrooms and 3 full baths, showcasing rich historical details throughout. Notable features include original hardware, intricate woodwork, window and door lintels, classic mantels, two staircases, an original outdoor beehive oven, Flemish bond brickwork, a carriage stone, and more. The main level welcomes you with a foyer featuring a traditional floorcloth, along with a formal living room, dining room, kitchen, full bath, and a family room—all enhanced by hardwood flooring and three fireplaces. The second level includes four bedrooms, two full baths (one with radiant flooring), two fireplaces, and access to a covered porch. The house heating source is primarily hot water radiator with minimal electric baseboard. The cooling source is central A/C and a full house fan. Additional storage is abundant with two outdoor sheds, as well as attic and basement space. Outside, a covered porch and hardscape patio offer a peaceful setting to enjoy the beautifully landscaped yard. This one-of-a-kind home is truly a must-see—schedule your private showing today to experience its character and history firsthand.

Location

Listed By

Listing Agent

Jenny S Stoner

jennystoner@remax.net
7178307573
RE/MAX Realty Agency, Inc.

Similar Listings

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
Virtual Tour
$442,740
4
2
1,698 Sq ft
6316 STERLING WAY, Ruther Glen, VA, 22546
MLS# VACV2009714
PENDING

Listing Office: D R Horton Realty of Virginia LLC

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
Newly Listed
$442,700
4
2
1,985 Sq ft
827 DISSTON VIEW DR, Lititz, PA, 17543
MLS# PALA2084240
ACTIVE

Listing Office: Apex Realty of Lancaster LTD

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
$442,500
4
3
1,875 Sq ft
453 LENAPE WAY, Claymont, DE, 19703
MLS# DENC2094664
ACTIVE

Listing Office: Compass

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
Newly Listed
$442,235
4
3
2,733 Sq ft
HOMESITE 365 LEADER RD, Inwood, WV, 25428
MLS# WVBE2049716
PENDING

Listing Office: DRB Group Realty, LLC

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
$442,000
4
3
1,440 Sq ft
641 49TH ST NE, Washington, DC, 20019
MLS# DCDC2254216
ACTIVE

Listing Office: Samson Properties

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
Newly Listed
$442,000
4
3
2,587 Sq ft
938 CHOLET DR, Collegeville, PA, 19426
MLS# PAMC2174528
UNDER CONTRACT

Listing Office: Realty One Group Supreme

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
Newly Listed
$442,000
4
3
2,450 Sq ft
624 STONEY RUN RD, Pottsville, PA, 17901
MLS# PASK2026694
ACTIVE

Listing Office: BHHS Homesale Realty - Schuylkill Haven

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
Newly Listed
$442,000
4
4
2,768 Sq ft
District Heights, MD, 20747
MLS# MDPG2200608
ACTIVE

Listing Office: Maryland Equity Solutions Inc

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
Virtual Tour
$441,990
4
3
2,277 Sq ft
307 BOXWOOD DR, Windsor, PA, 17366
MLS# PAYK2089862
ACTIVE

Listing Office: Patriot Realty, LLC

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
$441,990
4
3
2,533 Sq ft
2020 PAPERBACK WAY, York, PA, 17408
MLS# PAYK2100528
PENDING

Listing Office: D.R. Horton Realty of Pennsylvania

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
$441,900
4
4
1,800 Sq ft
306G BAUGHMANS LN, Frederick, MD, 21702
MLS# MDFR2079970
ACTIVE

Listing Office: Verdant Realty Group LLC

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
Newly Listed
$441,725
4
3
2,245 Sq ft
1511 MAPLE LN UNIT 185, Hanover, PA, 17331
MLS# PAYK2093918
PENDING

Listing Office: Joseph A Myers Real Estate, Inc.

46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225

No similar listings found

Unfortunately, we don't have any similar listings at the moment. Please remove or change some of the selected filters.
Print Details
46 N CARLISLE STREET, Greencastle, PA, 17225
Listing information provided courtesy of the Bright MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Updated: 6th May, 2026 11:39 PM (UTC)
Listing Agent: Jenny S Stoner
Listing Office: RE/MAX Realty Agency, Inc.
Attribution contact: 7178307573

Mortgage calculator

Created with Placester
Calculate total amount
Your monthly payment is:
$0.00
EHO
Realtor
EHO
Realtor
EHO
Realtor
EHO
Realtor
EHO
Realtor
EHO
Realtor
EHO
Realtor
EHO
Realtor